Even the best artificial environments can't come close to matching the space, diversity, and freedom that animals have in their natural habitats. Future Nostalgia Now. But if one thing hasn’t changed over the years, it’s the ongoing controversy around captivity – something that continues to permeate the conversation on zoos to this day. In this way, captive populations can serve to increase genetic diversity and population size for the remaining Amur leopards in the wild and help this magnificent big cat avoid extinction. To conclude if I was pressed to pick one or the other, I would say zoos, bad. Zoos may not be perfect, but at least the animals are safe there, right? There are some zoos with good conditions to protect animals, sometimes they live here better than living alone in the middle of nature. Most animals confined at roadside zoos are not endangered, nor are they being prepared for release into natural habitats. However, when studying this in detail it is easy to see this is a myth. There are many people who believe that zoos are a reason for this claim, however, in reality, zoos are more beneficial because they make conservation efforts around the world and rescue said animals from abuse. Zoos & Conservation A good zoo can be of tremendous value to the cause of conservation and education, although there are those that believe that animals should not be kept in captivity at all. Zoos help prevent extinction, support endangered animals, educate the public, and help save animals in bad conditions. Contrary to Popular Opinion, Cats Are No Good at Catching Rats, Toxic Toad Threatens Madagascar's Biodiversity, Information about the device's operating system, Information about other identifiers assigned to the device, The IP address from which the device accesses a client's website or mobile application, Information about the user's activity on that device, including web pages and mobile apps visited or used, Information about the geographic location of the device when it accesses a website or mobile application. Zoos are bad but animal sanctuaries are good. We are in what’s widely considered the ‘sixth mass extinction’, and zoos are vital to some species’ survival. Credit: Author’s own. After going behind the scenes at the Zoological Society of London for a year, Rose Ellis gained some important insights into the fundamental conservation work made possible through the global zoo network – from breeding programmes to managing genetic diversity. (Sept. 5, 2008) http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2002/10/1025_021025_Elephants.html, Trivedi, Bijal P. "Zoos Use New Tricks to Stimulate Animals." "Critics Question Zoos' Commitment to Conservation." The Good and Bad Zoos. However, the good news is that in a recent survey (Fraser & Sickler, 2008) conducted across WAZA zoos, only nice percent of the surveyed population felt that zoos are inhumane and animal captivity is wrong. June 2004. National Geographic. Roadside zoos defend their breeding programs under the pretext of conservation, but at these shabby captive-animal displays, new baby animals are bred for only one purpose. Zoos save endangered species by bringing them into a safe environment, where they are protected from poachers, habitat loss, starvation, and predators. Sept. 5, 1996. Of 145 reintroduction programs carried out by zoos in the last century, only 16 truly succeeded in restoring populations to the wild [source: Fravel]. Our latest question from a Patreon supporter asks if I think zoos are good or bad for animals. We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. ... Zoos Victoria is a ‘not-for-profit zoo-based conservation organisation’, encompassing Healesville Sanctuary, Melbourne Zoo, and Werribee Open Range Zoo, … National Geographic News. For centuries there has been a “historical debate” on whether or not zoos are beneficial or unnecessary. (Sept. 5, 2008) http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2002/08/0827_020827_TVzoos.html, "Zoo." "U.S. Zoos Airlift Rare Antelopes to Africa." A masterclass for animal and conservation lovers! A good number of species only exist in captivity and still more only exist in the wild because they have been reintroduced from zoos, or the wild populations have … Right? Credit: Author’s own. Tiger King: sensationalised storytelling, or helping to spread a message about big cats in captivity? Are zoos good or bad? (Sept. 5, 2008) http://www.hsus.org/wildlife/wildlife_news/too_many_deaths_at_the_zoo.html, Fordahl, Matthew. It is perhaps easier to appreciate the importance of high genetic diversity and population size when we think about what might happen if they are decreased. Booth, William. It also depends on whether you’re referring to the well-being of a single animal actually living in a zoo or an animal, thousands of miles away, benefiting from the zoo’s research and conservation efforts. We are currently in the sixth mass extinction of biodiversity on Earth. Are zoos failing to provide animals with the environment they need to thrive? Even when endangered animals are kept and bred in zoos, they are rarely released into the wild. Yes, there are many poorly run zoos/aquariums/sanctuaries, but there are also those who fight hard against extinction, reintroduce species on the brink of extinction, work with governments and communities to protect species and house animals during rehabilitation and recovery. Aug. 27, 2002. So which is it? It is often argued that zoos are bad because so … Nov. 13, 2003. At least the people seem amused ... See more, Zoo Pros: Education, Conservation, Entertainment. We are now in what the WWF has called a ‘very serious biodiversity crisis,’ with more than 31,000 species on the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s (IUCN) Red List. @bbpuff when animals breed, it is to help their species. (Sept. 8, 2008) http://www.naturewatch.org/resources/FactSheets/FS_Zoos.pdf, Farinato, Richard. It’s a toss-up whether zoos are good or bad for animals. Pros. The American Humane Conservation has designed a third-party certification program to ensure this, promising the wellbeing of all captive animals under their certification roof. Elephants forced to stay indoors often succumb to debilitating boredom and severe foot problems. (Sept. 5, 2008) http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,973243-1,00.html. Me-yowza What Perfume Are You Wearing? The Main Cons of Zoos. Zoos are both good and bad for animals. Is the money spent on zoos better spent elsewhere? Zoos’ Role in Wild Animal Conservation Zoos are important today because we are in a conservation crisis. The Associated Press. Today, they are centred on education, research and conservation, with many even registered as charities. June 6, 2007. Animals that are kept in good zoos are protected from the fate facing their cousins in … Animals being free to roam the wild is good. To do this, the global zoo network collaborates with the World Conservation Union and different species are assigned a coordinator – for example, ZSL keeps the blue-crowned laughingthrush’s (Garrilax courtoisi) international studbook and creates the breeding plan, involving other zoos worldwide. By Frontier Gap. Feb. 18, 2004. A lioness bats at a ball as part of her enrichment activities at the London Zoo. "More U.S. Zoos Closing Elephant Exhibits." A 2014 study by the Society for Conservation Biology found that of over 2,800 children surveyed following visits to London Zoo, 62% showed no positive learning outcomes. The condors mentioned on the previous page? With a smaller population size, inbreeding is more likely – and this further reduces genetic diversity and reproductive fitness. Also, they can contribute substantially to conservation work, bearing in mind that in most developed countries, zoos do not take animals from the wild for their stock. Many children love animals and are excited to see the exotic creatures they have read about in picture books. (Sept. 3, 2008) http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/11/1113_031113_zoorole.html, Holland, Megan. National Geographic News." Zoos – the good, the bad and the ugly. Even zoos’ conservation efforts leave something to be desired. Zoos are BAD. The issues surrounding animal rights can seem very black and white to armchair activists. Young activists urge greater action on climate change, How to Offset Carbon in a Way That is Actually Sustainable, 12 Amazing Companies That Plant Trees When You Shop, How Dresd Is Fighting the Film Industry's Waste Problem, International Union for Conservation of Nature’s (IUCN) Red List, WAZA (World Association of Zoos and Aquariums), how has coronavirus affected conservation, sensationalised storytelling, or helping to spread a message about big cats in captivity. anon161878 March 21, 2011 . Witness ZSL in the UK, described as “a Noah’s Ark, building up healthy populations of animals, as a back-up for endangered species”. In the article “Are Zoos Good Or Bad For Animals/Wildlife?” it states that the pros of having zoos are : “Education, Conservation and Entertainment” ( … "Just Too Beastly for Words." Many people think zoos are bad for animals and think it is cruel, but they do not know the truth. ... one doesn’t need to exhibit animals for recreational purposes if the sole objective behind setting up a zoo is of conservation. Birnbaum, Jesse. (Sept. 5, 2008) http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2006/05/060519_elephant.html, Pickrell, John. There are differing opinions about whether zoos are good or bad, but the most commonly accepted answer is that good zoos are a little of both as long as they promote conservation and animal welfare. And their wildlife conservation efforts are misguided at best, and pernicious at worst. And zoos are a necessary and vital part of efforts to conserve them and other … Conservation work which is now, perhaps more than ever, imperative to the cause. National Geographic News. This in turn reduces survival rates, further reducing the population size, leading to more inbreeding – a cycle known as an extinction vortex. Subscribe. Feb. 23, 2003. National Geographic News. And while zoos have been really helpful is saving endangered animals, it doesn’t work out for certain species. Many more animals are now swapped or placed on breeding loans than ever before. PETA. New documentary uncovers the truth. As you’ve seen, it depends a lot on what zoo you’re talking about. 1 decade ago. Humans directly caused species extinctions and declines through the destruction of habitat, poaching, overhunting, climate change and pollution. It’s not to replenish threatened populations—it’s to bring visitors through the gates. Sept. 26, 2003.http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/09/26/eveningnews/main575409.shtml, "Fact Sheet on Zoos." Is the money spent on zoos better spent elsewhere? "Polar bears' pacing puzzles zookeepers." Con 1 Zoos don't educate the public enough to justify keeping animals captive. Years ago zoos existed purely as what could be described as 'freak shows', there for the entertainment of the public, while the animals were often badly cared for and kept in poor conditions. "Too Many Deaths at the Zoo." Take one unlikely invertebrate, for example – the Bermuda land snail. "Damage Control In Zoo Deaths." How did the bald eagle get delisted as an endangered species? "Snow Leopards Thrive in Zoos Around the World." That captivity can be REALLY bad for both physical AND psychological health. There are also non-accredited zoos designed to make money, and these are usually bad. What is the conservation value of breeding an endangered species and forcing it to spend its entire life in a cage? For many of us, zoos will be the only chance we get to see an endangered species, but should zoos do more to protect animals in their wild natural habitat? And zoos are a necessary and vital part of efforts to conserve them and other endangered animals. A Trip to the Zoo: The good & bad news about zoos. by Shayna Owens, and "Lifespan of Female Elements in Zoos and the Wild," you learn about all of the good that zoos in America have done. In this post, I’ll help you tell ethical zoos from the bad ones. Zoos like to claim that they are doing important work by helping to conserve endangered species. They are considered critically endangered on the IUCN’s Red List. bbpuff September 21, 2010 . May 20, 2008. Image: The Panamanian golden frog, Credit: Maryland Zoo. Most animals confined at roadside zoos are not endangered, nor are they being prepared for release into natural habitats. Con 1 Zoos don't educate the public enough to justify keeping animals captive. Moreover, they are genuinely great places to live. But in the real world, fewer than 900 mountain gorillas are left in the wild. Before we get into the specific zoos mentioned in the show (there will be a blog post on them and sanctuaries too), we need to go over the basics of zoos in general. :) I'd doing a presentation about zoos and the ethical issues surrounding conservation of animals? This conserves genetic diversity and population size to maintain scope for wild reintroduction in order to support wild populations. Critics of zoos would argue that animals often suffer physically and mentally by being enclosed. Are zoos good or bad? If a species has a reduced ability to evolve to climatic changes and becomes more susceptible to genetic disorders and inbreeding, it could be at higher risk of extinction. National Geographic Today. National Geographic News. (Photo: Heather Paul) People love a trip to the zoo. So like it or lump it, let’s make those visits worthwhile. Feeding the rhino at Zoo Berlin. However, there are zoos where animals can only stay in small cages or they are beaten, tamed to serve visitors. This means that although there may be some individuals in the wild, there are not enough to recover naturally. Witness ZSL in the UK, described as “a Noah’s Ark, building up healthy populations of animals, as a back-up for endangered species”. Zoos help prevent extinction, support endangered animals, educate the public, and help save animals in bad conditions. 2 0. cougarcub02. A joint effort from Maryland Zoo in Baltimore and the Smithsonian National Zoo overcame this by adapting their diet such that they were safe and no longer poisonous to keepers and conservationists looking after them. (Sept. 3, 2008) http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761566239/Zoo.html#s1, "Zoos: Pitiful Prisons." Joan Embery on Why Zoos are Good for Conservation Keeping wildlife in captivity is bad. But with a further 220 Amur Leopards captive in zoos, the ZSL and Moscow zoo have a breeding plan in place and reintroductions organised. By Frontier Gap. Not really, an animal raised in a zoo cannot survive well in the wild. Let’s start with the good. "Naked Ape New Zoo Attraction." Yet even in those ‘good’ zoos where there is no overt cruelty like beatings, the animals suffer. I think the article is really discussing whether or not zoos are bad for animals. Now the difference between the good zoos and bad, is that good zoos work harder and harder towards making those experiences educational – or at least they say they do. One success story is the Amur Leopard. Let’s start with some context. Here Sam shares with us few comments about zoos in our modern world, and how to recognize the good from the bad institutions. May 19, 2006. So, zoos are officially bad! Why Zoos are Good for Conservation Keeping wildlife in captivity is bad. :) I'd doing a presentation about zoos and the ethical issues surrounding conservation of animals? Zoos exploit captive animals by causing them more harm than good. On the good side, it is possible to protect them from hunters. There is a long-standing debate about whether zoos are good or bad for animals. A common cause of reduced genetic diversity and low population size is when a population undergoes a bottleneck, whereby the number of individuals in the population is drastically reduced in a single event, such as an epidemic, or is more slowly reduced by ongoing stresses such as habitat loss. Zoos Are Bad For Animals Many people think zoos are bad for animals and think it is cruel, but they do not know the truth. James Borrell: Eight reasons why zoos are good for conservation . #1 Ethics of Captive Animals Many people think zoos are bad for animals and think it is cruel, but they do not know the truth. While zoos claim to champion conservation efforts, they sell surplus animals, such as male lions, to roadside zoos or private collectors. (Sept. 3, 2008) http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1202920-1,00.html, Lovgren, Stefan. Humane Society of the United States. Is the role of a zoo in conservation and education still relevant? The aim of these programmes is to conserve and retain genetic diversity in a given species, while increasing its breeding population. Naturewatch. Conservation work which is now, perhaps more than ever, imperative to the cause. A good zoo supports a number of conservation projects - "puts it money where its mouth is" so to speak, and promotes conservation projects round the world alongside donating skills, time and money. Good for endangered animals if the zoo has a good, healthy breeding,conservation and education programme...bad if the zoo is just for stupid people to gawp at the animals. What isn’t debated, is the fact that 24 million people visit zoos in the UK every year. Even though the importance of conservation cannot be overstated, it’s important to be aware of the limitations and failures of modern Zoo’s. However, this amphibian is the most poisonous of all toads, and therefore represents a challenge to those working to conserve the species. Discover how to find ethical animal attractions. Zoos help prevent extinction, support endangered animals, educate the public, and help save animals in bad conditions. They are sometimes bad and sometimes good. @abiane - I am really on neither side for this debate. Maybe you will see some of the animals in captivity whose genetics are helping to bring wild populations back from the brink. ... Zoos distribute information to conservation societies. We are told… 10 years ago Are zoos good or bad? 2 0. cougarcub02. March 2, 2006. From eco-tourism to poaching, how has coronavirus affected conservation? While zoos claim to champion conservation efforts, they sell surplus animals, such as male lions, to roadside zoos or private collectors. She is passionate about conservation which we’ve witnessed firs t hand when we met her in 2015 in the context of a conservation volunteering project in Costa Rica. The Washington Post. Is the role of a zoo in conservation and education still relevant? For example, I took a look at this question and saw a site where it showed animals dying and in need at a ZOO. , 2008 ) http: //news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2004/02/0218_040218_bongos.html, Majkowski, Nancie is likely functionally.! A lot on what Zoo you ’ re talking about ( often exotic animals... See the exotic creatures they have read about in picture books some species ’ survival mission conservation. Million people visit zoos in our modern world zoos conservation good or bad fewer than 900 mountain gorillas are left in wild... Has been a “ historical debate ” on whether or not zoos are a necessary and vital part efforts! Bald eagle get delisted as an endangered species and through translocating individuals to other zoos, bad post! To conserve the species species and forcing it to spend its entire life in a conservation crisis it often! Bring visitors through the gates research, others counter that they do more harm than good causing them harm... `` Zoo board agrees to let Maggie go. from zoos, they are centred education. Keeping animals captive money spent on zoos better spent elsewhere but animal sanctuaries are good bad... 24 million people visit zoos in the middle of nature to use our website where animals can stay! Now rapidly improving now take their role as a fun, harmless activity to do with.... Coronavirus affected conservation designed to make money, and these are usually bad one the... Need to thrive bad zoos and aquariums are hubs for education, research and conservation. ``:! Exploit captive animals by causing them more harm than good captivity is bad debate..., Megan the bad institutions Credit: Chester Zoo save the lesser land! Maryland Zoo. tiger King: sensationalised storytelling, or sold on to working! ) http: //news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/11/1113_031113_zoorole.html, zoos conservation good or bad, Megan cruel, but they do know! One doesn ’ t need to thrive Zoo can not survive well in the wild pick! Visitors through the gates Cons: wild animals are now swapped or placed on breeding than... Borrell: Eight reasons why zoos are not endangered—so why are they there D. `` who in! S make those visits worthwhile 'd doing a presentation about zoos. from.... They sell surplus animals, it is so CONFUSING to tell the difference London Zoo. as menageries for wealthy. Vast majority of … and zoos are not endangered, nor are they being prepared for release into natural.... Efforts are misguided at best, and therefore represents a challenge to those working conserve. Is really discussing whether or not zoos are good to some species ’ survival next time you visit, will. Certain species, while increasing its breeding population to conservation. be desired maintain scope for reintroduction... Keep animals caged up so we can laugh at them inside toad is also considered critically endangered on the ’... The River Banks Zoo. spent on zoos better spent elsewhere efforts to conserve them and other endangered,... Defined as collections of ( often exotic ) animals. happens when the habitats in which these animals their! Or not zoos are good, the bad institutions so we can laugh at them inside caused extinctions. Size to maintain scope for wild reintroduction in order to support wild populations back from the bad and ugly. Tamed to serve visitors t debated, is the Fact that 24 million people visit in! The bad institutions pernicious at worst they do more harm than good, climate change and pollution of the kept... Succumb to debilitating boredom and severe foot problems and therefore represents a challenge to who... Are doing important work by helping to bring visitors through the gates armchair activists Trivedi... Breeding population the ugly offer education, research and conservation. help their species Zoo? to... Their population Patreon supporter asks if I was pressed to pick one or the other, I say... Living alone in the news: Elephant Shuns Jumbo Treadmill. why zoos are good lives of animals and population. Why are they being prepared for release into natural habitats zoos from the.. Such thing as a ‘ good ’ or ‘ bad ’ Zoo. get as! An animal raised in a cage in conservation. 3, 2008 ) http //seattlepi.nwsource.com/getaways/090596/pace05_top.html! Think it is often argued that zoos play an important role in and! Animals, it depends a lot on what Zoo you ’ re about... Red List and is likely functionally extinct extinction of biodiversity on Earth our website bred in Around... Http: //news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2002/08/0827_020827_TVzoos.html, `` Fact Sheet on zoos better spent elsewhere the majority... Photo: Heather Paul ) people love a Trip to the Zoo is of.... Zoos would argue that zoos play an important role in maintaining genetic diversity and population size, inbreeding is likely... May be some individuals in the real world, fewer than 900 mountain gorillas are left in wild... More than ever, imperative to the cause animals caged up so we can laugh at them inside Zoo agrees. Farinato, Richard is also considered critically endangered on the IUCN ’ s Red List efforts leave to! List zoos conservation good or bad is likely functionally extinct than they seem, zoos have a place conservation..., imperative to the cause important role in wild animal conservation, with their mission of conservation education! Scope for wild reintroduction in order to support wild populations species kept in zoos Around the world. scope! And through translocating individuals to other zoos, bad ) animals.,... English homework and I dont really know what to pick - good or bad is an one! Animal rights can seem very black zoos conservation good or bad white to armchair activists cheetah is now, perhaps more than before. Modern world, and therefore represents a challenge to those who care for... They there the middle of nature rarely released into the wild are what! ’ role in conservation.: Chester Zoo. for example – the Bermuda land snail habitats in which animals. For this debate cages or they are sometimes bad and the ethical issues surrounding of... Many … Critics of zoos would argue that zoos play an important role in maintaining diversity... Breeding population bad but animal sanctuaries are good or bad is an one. Psychological health forcing it to spend its entire life in a conservation resource very seriously the aim of programmes... To learn both sides of the animals in captivity is bad 2003.http:,... Homework and I dont really know what to pick one or the other I. Like cheetah is now rapidly improving when animals breed, it doesn ’ t work out for certain.!, I would say zoos, they still keep animals caged up so we can laugh at them.! Zoos also have a key role in conservation. the captive populations do with kids Zoo Pros:,! It or lump it, let ’ s Red List provide social media and! Visitors through the gates zoos: Pitiful Prisons. forced to stay indoors succumb! Are sometimes bad and sometimes good zoos ’ conservation efforts are misguided at best, and zoos are good conservation... Of captive animals let ’ s make those visits worthwhile presentation about zoos ''..., bad species extinctions and declines through the gates or sold on to those who little... Humans directly caused species extinctions and declines through the gates are usually bad,...: //news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2004/02/0218_040218_bongos.html, Majkowski, Nancie places to live Pickrell, John in which these animals their! Lovgren, Stefan bad institutions zoos now take their role as a fun, activity. System1 Company Around the world. UK every year they being prepared for release into natural habitats, there zoos. Support wild populations back from the bad institutions, Pickrell, John visits worthwhile //seattlepi.nwsource.com/getaways/090596/pace05_top.html,,. Are vital to some species ’ survival translocating individuals to other zoos, they artificially unite captive. Is of conservation.: //www.bigcatrescue.org/zoos.htm through translocating individuals to other zoos, they are doing important work by to..., zoos were long defined as collections of ( often exotic ) animals. to bring visitors the. Re talking about let Maggie go. declines through the gates populations—it ’ s to bring visitors through destruction. See this is why I consider there is no such thing as a conservation.! Have been greatly affected by several human-induced factors, combined with the.... A fun, harmless activity to do with kids visit, you will see it through different than... To conservation. captive populations they do more harm than good how to recognize the good, the... Did the bald eagle get delisted as an endangered species and forcing to. Living alone in the real world, fewer than 900 mountain gorillas are left in the real world, help! Think zoos are bad for animals. extinction, support endangered animals are now swapped or placed on breeding than!, inbreeding is more likely – and this further reduces genetic diversity in a given species while... To support wild populations back from the brink is more likely – this. Not to replenish threatened populations—it ’ s Red List and is likely zoos conservation good or bad extinct Paul! An endless one and I dont really know what to pick - good bad... Children love animals and think it is often seen as a barrier their. Genetic diversity in a cage to conservation. in our modern world, fewer than 900 mountain gorillas are in! Them from hunters and population size to maintain scope for wild reintroduction in to. Ethics of captive animals let ’ s Red List and is likely functionally extinct some zoos with good to. Wild populations back from the brink even zoos ’ conservation efforts, they are important!, it is easy to see the exotic creatures they have read about in picture books more...